Winner: Mariah Carey
Mariah largely took the high road during the showdown but she brought the diva out at the next judging. The judges had been clearly instructed to play nice but Mariah couldn’t help throwing in a little blow. The singer made fun of a contestant wearing a hat, calling it cartoonish, at the exact time that her nemesis just so happened to be wearing a strange hat. Sub-trash talking Nicki’s accessories? You’re so cold, Mariah.