The-Return The-Return

Interview: Makers Of 'The Return' Documentary Uncover Civilian Adjustment After Life Sentences

Directed by Kelly Duane de la Vega and Katie Galloway, 'The Return' looks into the criminal justice system and the repeal of California's controversial Three Strikes Rule. 

 

In The Return, a wave of relief washes over Kenneth Anderson's family when they're informed his life sentence is cut short. Tears streamed down the face of his 24-year-old daughter while his ex-wife Monica comforts her. Anderson served 14 years in a California prison for a nonviolent drug offense under the state's notorious 1994 "Three Strikes" law, which gave thousands life sentences for petty crimes. Other states implement similar practices. Drug addicts, the mentally ill and people of color were the recipients of the incredibly harsh sentences, an afterthought lawmakers ignored in efforts to keep the "bad guys" off the street.

After voters passed Proposition 36 in 2012 to repeal the law, many became eligible for early releases. One of them was Anderson, but his release was just one hurdle he had to face.

The documentary—put together by three-time Emmy Award-winners Kelly Duane de la Vega and Katie Galloway—tell the stories of former 'lifers' like Anderson and Bilal Kevin Chatman finding they way back to normal life, the advocates who push for re-entry programs and the judges who hold the future of the disenfranchised in their hands.

The efforts of de-institutionalizing offenders are slim to none, with the lack of support to counter the trauma faced behind the cell walls. Since Prop 36 passed, 2,100 Three Strikers have been released with a recidivism rate under 9 percent. The efforts of Prop 36 will more than likely save Californians $1.3 billion over the next 10 years, but what remains today is a harsh reality.

After five months on the job, Anderson is fired and reverts back to using drugs, affecting his family tremendously. They're able to help him find treatment and he lands on his feet once again. With the huge lag of re-entry laws and programs, will other former offenders find themselves on a ferris wheel of internal struggle? VIBE spoke to Galloway and de la Vega via email about the stories behind the documentary and what lies ahead for the criminal justice system.

VIBE: Do you think sentencing laws have been strengthened or weakened over the years?  
Kelly Duane de la Vega and Katie Galloway: Since the mid-80s, when the nation first passed bi-partisan “tough on crime laws,” our country has come to incarcerate more people than any other nation in the world. With 5 percent of the world’s population, we have 25 percent of the world’s prisoners.  With our prison system growing, so too are its prisoners, hundreds of thousands of them “aging out” of criminal behavior yet remaining incarcerated at a cost of 65K a year per person. Not only does our draconian system of mass incarceration make no practical or financial sense—it’s inhumane. While in the past few years we’ve begun to see incremental reform, there is much left to be done both in terms of transforming future policy and reckoning with the legacy of decades of destructive policies. As a nation, we need to not only rethink the length of our sentences but also our approach to rehabilitation and re-entry. More than 650,000 people are released every year, only to face nearly insurmountable obstacles to obtaining housing, education, and gainful employment.

What was the inspiration for making The Return
When we learned that Prop. 36 was on the ballot and that, if passed, it would mark the first time ever that citizens opted to shorten sentences of the currently incarcerated. We were determined to follow the story, to provide a lens through which to explore the idea of undoing what we’ve done, i.e. mass incarceration writ large. We began by creating a series of shorts examining those actually serving life under 3xs in California - knowing there were a lot of false assumptions about this population as “the worst of the worst.” Our goal was to produce intimate, close-to-the-bone narratives while providing a vantage point from which to consider the question that is also the conceptual project motivating the feature film: after a half century of building this behemoth, how do we go about unbuilding?

How do you feel about the children of incarcerated parents? Why are they often left out of the conversation? 
The War on Drugs and our draconian sentencing policies have devastated the lives of millions of American children and untold families and communities. One of the reasons we focused on the Anderson/Grier family was to bring those children to the center of the conversation over mass incarceration and its legacy: to raise the profile of those who’ve loved and lost family members to prison. Those “serving time on the outside." There are millions of Americans suffering with a feeling of shame and loss due to an absent parent. We have to start looking at our justice and incarceration systems in a more holistic way that acknowledges the punishing and destructive impact on children and families. If we do, we strongly believe our society will be safer and more just for all.

What does redemption mean to those who have served their time for their crimes? 
In prison, a lot of programming is focused on seeking redemption for one’s crimes. It seems to be the singular focus of many explanations given and expected - and we don’t underestimate the value of “taking responsibility” as a part of recovery and healing. But that focus often denies and belies many of the structural factors that lead people to become incarcerated in the first place. The lack of quality public education and decent work, the disparities in punishment for the poor and people of color, the lack of health care and services, the list goes on. People who have suffered the greatest inequities and injustices in American society are, not surprisingly, the most likely to suffer the brunt of dystopic policies. And they’re also most likely to be disenfranchised and to suffer the implications of not having political power and voice. The untold story of redemption in America—one that still hangs in the balance—is our collective redemption, only just beginning to show signs of life and desperately in need of nurturing and growing if we’re going to make the so called “change moment” on criminal justice real.  We need collective redemption for endorsing harsh sentencing policies that have yielded a profound human rights crisis in our nation. We believe the passage of Prop 36 and Prop 47 two years later signal a meaningful shift in public thinking around our prison system, and have highlighted public shame for and desire to correct what has taken place on our watch.

What can you say about the attorneys who continue to fight for better laws in the criminal justice system? 
We are both daughters of civil rights lawyers raised with the question of what constitutes justice as dinner table conversation. We have the deepest respect for Mike Romano, Susan Champion, Emily Galvin, David Mills, Jessica Delgado and many more public defenders and legal advocates who have fought hard from the trenches to the media to the halls of power—all against the odds—to pass and choreograph the success of this unprecedented and hopeful reform. Their struggle for justice, their generosity of spirit, and their deep empathy inspire us and motivate our work — work we hope will in turn inspire new generations to walk in their footsteps, holding our nation closer to its promise of liberty and justice for all.

The film, an audience favorite at the Tribeca Film Festival, will air as part of PBS' POV (Point of View) series tonight (May 23) at 10 p.m. Learn more about the film at thereturnproject.com.

From the Web

More on Vibe

Getty Images

Dr. King's Childhood Home Sold For $1.9 Million To The National Park Service

The two-story Atlanta home that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr spent his formidable years has been sold. According to the Atlanta-Journal Constitution, the yellow and brown house on Auburn Avenue in Atlanta was sold for $1.9 million to the National Park Service.

Will Shafroth, CEO of the National Park Foundation said it was hard to place a dollar amount on the location where a lot of Dr. King's character was molded.

"It is difficult to value something this significant in our nation’s history. It is a priceless asset. It is one of the most important places to tell the story of America,” Shafroth said.

Bernice King, daughter of late the civil rights leader, said the King Center for Nonviolent Social Change had been considering selling the home since the passing of their mother Coretta Scott, in 2006. King said the center will focus on nonviolent educational and training programs.

“We are working on creating more robust, nonviolence training,” King said. “Our society is desperately in need of Dr. King’s nonviolent teachings right now in order to create a just, humane and peaceful world. That is what we are trying to put our energy in.”

The home was reportedly built by a white firefighter in 1895 and then purchased by Dr. King's maternal grandfather, Rev. Adam Daniel Williams, who was pastor at Ebenezer Baptist Church for $3,500. When King's mother and father wed in 1927, they moved. All of King's siblings including himself were born in the home.

Elizabeth Paradis Stern, spokeswoman for the National Park Service said the preservation of the home will not falter now that it's out of the family's possession.

“The most important thing about this is that this property will be protected and preserved permanently as one of our most important properties,” Stern said. “It is part of the American fabric.”

READ MORE: New Book Details Dr. King's Teenage Years And His Alleged White Girlfriend

Continue Reading
Kevin Winter

Donnie McClurkin Sent To Hospital Following Car Accident

Gospel legend Donnie McClurkin couldn't be more grateful after surviving a car accident this past Wednesday (Dec. 12).

The "We Fall Down" singer was driving on the road in the earlier part of the day when he passed out and began weaving into traffic. He reportedly struck the middle concrete island.

Following the incident, he posted a selfie of him on the hospital bed in scrubs on Facebook. Along with the photo, he explained that he woke up from the accident with stitches on his left thumb, on top of having a sprained wrist, and hurt knee. His car was also completely totaled.

"I AM ALIVE!!!! Somewhat mangled, stitches on left thumb, sprained wrist, hurt knee, but I’m still here! God and two angels saved my life!," the Grammy-winning artist wrote.

He also mentioned that two "angels" pulled him out the car to safety and medical attention. "I owe them...I am still here by the grace of God! Thank you, Lord...thank you!" he added.

On Friday (Dec. 14), McClurkin posted to his Facebook page again, sharing several photos of his destroyed car. "This is the totaled car that two angels rescued me from ....after passing out while driving I don’t remember most of what happened a day and a half ago...but God," he wrote. "I overrode doctors and sisters advice and flew to KENYA today for ministry Saturday @ TWO RIVERS. and home on this Sunday to celebrate life."

In happier news, McClurkin also took time to plug in his new Christmas single titled "My Favorite Things." Check out McClurkin's posts on social media and stream his new song below.

READ MORE: Big K.R.I.T. Drops Surprise Gospel-Influenced 'Thrice X' EP

Continue Reading
Douglas Grundy

Nicki Minaj's Boyfriend Kenneth Petty Received 18 Violations During Prison Stint

Nicki Minaj's new boyfriend, Kenneth Petty has a very troubled past.

On Friday (Dec. 14), TMZ revealed court documents disclosing Petty's history of disciplinary actions while he was an inmate in New York for manslaughter from 2006 to 2013.

When he entered the correctional facility, he was reportedly written up for creating a disturbance. Later during his stint, he was hit with a slew of disciplinary actions following a series of violent actions that included fighting, making terroristic threats, and "disobeying a direct order."

In 2009, prison faculty placed him in solitary confinement for four months as part of being reprimanded for nine different violations. Petty lost privileges that included the usage of the inmate telephone service, recreational activity, and the prison canteen.

In addition to his prison violations, Petty is a convicted sex offender. At the age of 16, he was tried as an adult served a four-year sentence for attempted rape of a minor.

Petty, who hails from the same borough as Nicki, Queens, knew the platinum-selling rap star since she was a teenager. They dated for a short period years prior to reuniting.

Minaj posted various photos of her and Petty going on a vacation getaway earlier this month. Sources close to Minaj told the celebrity gossip website that the 36-year-old hip-hop artist is  "happier than she's been in years" with Petty.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Barbie® (@nickiminaj) on Dec 10, 2018 at 12:43pm PST

READ MORE: Nicki Minaj Plans To Sue 'Daily Mail' TV Host Jesse Palmer

Continue Reading

Top Stories