The Story Of Pablo Escobar Through A White Man's Lens Is A Big Problem

Anglo writers are still doing a disservice to Latinx narratives. 

Hollywood absolutely adores drug lord films. From City of God to Scarface, casting Latinx actors as ruthless, materialistic, villainous killing machines determined to maintain multibillion dollar narcotic empires remains an age-old favorite of mainstream television and film writers, leaving their characters devoid of multifaceted human complexity. According to Caitlin Cruz at Fusion, that's precisely the problem.

More pointedly, Cruz takes issue with Narcos, a Netflix crime-drama series that follows the rise and fall of infamous cocaine trafficker, Pablo Escobar. "Narcos follows a long tradition of Latinx actors and actresses being cast as drug lords, users, mules, sicarios, lieutenants, and every other role required to have a moderately functional drug empire," she explains. "Just to give you an idea: There’s Mr. Robot, Weeds, Breaking Bad, Sicario, Escobar: Paradise Lost, Blow, Bad Boyz II, Queen of the South, The Infiltrator, Suicide Squad, White Girl, Traffic, Savages, every iteration of the Law & Order franchise, Veronica Mars, Jennifer Lopez’s yet-to-be-named TV movie about the “Cocaine Godmother” of Colombia, and Univision’s own El Chapo."

Instead of the story being narrated by Escobar, the story is mainly told through the character of Steve Murphy, a DEA agent who infiltrated and brought down the Medellin cartel in the 1980s. "Murphy is one of the few white people in the show, and yet he’s still the one guiding us through the cocaine-streaked and bloody battle for Colombia’s soul—at least, that’s how Murphy describes the hunt for Escobar. Twenty episodes in, Murphy has guided us into battle, berated Colombians for not speaking English, and posed for pictures with Escobar’s bleeding corpse. Narcos, for all its effort, is about a white man's journey through one of the deadliest portions of Colombian history," Cruz continues.

While Narcos provides a window of opportunity for its writers to dissect the politics of the international drug trafficking in Colombia as well as the effect the trade had on Indigenous and African communities in South America, it instead casts Latinx actors as props, and centers white perspectives. "Murphy, played with jaded tough-guy sincerity by Boyd Holbrook, shares [an insight] in Season 1, about how Colombia is a 'country where dreams and reality are conflated.' A generous viewer might dismiss this reductive condescension as meta-commentary on the irredeemable whiteness of his character. But Narcos goes out of its way to endorse Murphy’s sneering gringo sensibilities as its own," adds New Republic writer Steven Cohen.

Season 2 of Narcos also proves to be extremely problematic in its portrayal of Afro-Latinx and female characters. "Colombia’s drug war has profound racial dimensions, but the sole black character of note on Season 2 (Julián Díaz) is a hit man literally named 'Blackie' ," Cohen continues. "The extent of his backstory is a pregnant girlfriend who appears in two scenes before being murdered." While the show aims to provide more depth to Latinx women than before in Season 1, other than strictly relegating their roles for sexual objectification, the new roles, are as Cohen puts it, "shallow in their conception and secondary in their importance."

Narcos is but a reminder of the film industry's refusal to cast Latinx actors and actresses in varied roles and their obsession with creating apolitical, shallow characters. Hollywood is rife with white writers who are content not challenging themselves to write more compelling content that captures the different aspects of the Latinx community; thereby, casting actors such as Benicio del Toro, Salma Hayek, and Aaron Zebede in drug lord films becomes crushingly de rigueur.

Cruz notes that at this point, the fallback to the Latinx drug lord role in Hollywood, is stagnating the imagination of the audience. "At this point, it’s just lazy, both intellectually and culturally. It’s boring. And we are rewarding boring... a larger examination of television and movies shows that over and over again, the Latinx stories being greenlighted, funded, written, and shot are about the drug trade. It’s easy to forget that when you don’t spend every season scouring cast lists and production names for someone who looks like you. Even in an age where Gina Rodriguez wins a Golden Globe for the titular role in Jane The Virgin, a show that includes varied and multifaceted Latinx characters, white creators are still obsessed with telling drug king’s stories."

While Cruz remains adamant that Latinx writers must find avenues to tell their own stories, she also remains critical of the role that white people play in divulging stories to Hollywood.

"How about this? White people are no longer allowed to make media about Latinx people for the foreseeable future. Sorry, I didn’t want to have to make the rules, but you’ve pushed me to the breaking point. Until morale improves, I’m revoking your privileges. Please send scripts to me for approval. They’ll be discussed at the next meeting."

From the Web

More on Vibe

Bad Bunny performs onstage during Calibash Los Angeles 2018 at Staples Center on January 20, 2018 in Los Angeles, California.
Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Bad Bunny's "Safaera" Inspires Hilarious #AbuelaChallenge

While we're keeping social distancing in mind during the coronavirus pandemic, being at home has inspired families to dive into the unknown–abuelas jamming to Bad Bunny.

Remezcla discovered the very hilarious #AbuelaChallenge, inspired by the artist's latest track "Safaera" featuring Ñengo Flow and duo Jowell & Randy. Although there was a more rump-shaking #safaerachallenge in place, this one is way better as we watch generations bond a very 2020 way.

Originally appearing on Tik Tok, the challenge found its way to Instagram with plenty of elders getting down on the floor...or being completely over it.

Benito recently dropped his sophomore project, YHLQMDLG (Yo Hago lo Que me da la Gana) meaning "I Do What I Want" featuring guest spots by Sech, Anuel AA, Myke Towers, Arcangel and more.

Jam to it here and see our favorites from the challenge below.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Yolanda Javier (@experience_24fitmom) on Mar 8, 2020 at 1:09pm PDT



View this post on Instagram


A post shared by DAVIANA ✨ (@davi__ana) on Mar 9, 2020 at 6:21pm PDT



View this post on Instagram


Jijiji #abuelachallenge #safaera #badbunny #safaerachallenge @yosoymolusco @rockythekid @badbunnypr @jowellyrandy @jowellgram @randynotagram

A post shared by ✨✨ (@babykchic) on Mar 12, 2020 at 1:31pm PDT



View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Jowell & Randy (Reggaeton Duo) (@jowellyrandy) on Mar 18, 2020 at 5:58am PDT



View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Nelson Jotaa (@nelsonjotaa) on Mar 17, 2020 at 3:09pm PDT

Continue Reading
Rapper Tekashi69, real name Daniel Hernandez and also known as 6ix9ine, Tekashi 6ix9ine, Tekashi 69, leaves after his arraignment on assault charges in County Criminal Court #1 at the Harris County Courthouse on August 22, 2018 in Houston, Texas.
Photo by Bob Levey/Getty Images

Fashion Nova Launches $2.25 Million Lawsuit Against Tekashi69

Tekashi69 has an unlikely foe in Fashion Nova. The fast-fashion brand has taken legal action against the jailed rapper after he failed to promote their clothing.

According to TMZ, the brand claims in October 2018 they planned to roll out a series of branded social posts and with the rapper. With over 13 million followers on Instagram, Fashion Nova wanted to capitalize on his rapid popularity with hopes he would mention them in a song or two but was unaware of his legal troubles. During this time, 69, born Daniel Hernandez, was paid a $250,000 advance.

The awkward part comes next. Two weeks later, the rapper was arrested for his sex video case (more on that here), an aspect of his life the brand says they were unaware of. With his criminal troubles more popular than his music, Fashion Nova felt his trial revealed he wasn't the best person to rep the brand.

After his team failed to provide them with this information and return the advance, the brand decided to take legal action. The brand is currently suing him for $2.25 million– just a few months before his rumored released date of August 2020.

On the weird upside, the rapper is expected to release a project the same month. While his Instagram page hasn't been updated in a year, the last post was dedicated to the release of his debut album Dummy Boy. 


View this post on Instagram



A post shared by 6ix9ine (@6ix9ine) on Nov 18, 2018 at 2:45pm PST

Read our timeline on the infamous rapper titled Rise To Fame: A Timeline Of Tekashi 6ix9ine's Controversial Moments here. 

Continue Reading

Alejandro Sanz And Juanes Team Up To Deliver Special Jam Session For Fans On YouTube

As concerts and festivals see cancellations across the globe, artists are thinking outside the box to provide music to their fans. Case in point, Latin legends Alejandro Sanz And Juanes put their resources together for a special live-streamed concert after both of their shows were canceled due to the coronavirus.

Both artists were slated to perform in Columbia over the weekend with Juanes's Para Todos (For All) show in Bogotà and Sanz's La Gira (The Tour) in Bogotá and Cali, respectively. With both stars residing in Miami, Sanz and Juanes linked with Art House Miami music studio to stream a special concert with a Q&A section and new performances covers.

Timed for maximum accessibility to unite fans in Europe, The United States, and throughout Latin America, “ALEJANDRO SANZ & JUANES: El Gira Se Queda En Casa Para Todos” (The Tour Stays Home For All) aired on YouTube Live Sunday (March 15).

Renowned producer Julio Reyes Copello, pianist Gonzalo Rubalcaba, bassist Guillermo Vadalá and very minimal studio staff were used to regulate social distancing.

The experiment kicks off a unique method of providing fans with entertainment. The artists have encouraged others to do the same in order to heal the world (at least a bit) with the sound of music.

Check out the concert above.

Continue Reading

Top Stories