Zola Mashariki
Getty Images

Viacom Moves To Dismiss Ex-BET Exec's "Shotgun Pleading" In Discrimination Lawsuit

Zola Mashariki's departure is at the center of a dispute in California federal court.

Not enough facts to support a legal claim. Too many facts to provide a concise and clear summary of wrongdoing. Those are the two argumentative strategies that defendants generally use in attempting to dismiss a complaint at the outset of a lawsuit when judges are beholden to accept the truth of a plaintiff's allegations. In moving to reject claims made by Zola Mashariki, formerly the head of originals at Black Entertainment Television, her ex-employer has opted to contend she's asserting too much without direction in what is being described as a "shotgun pleading."

Mashariki filed suit earlier this month, alleging that BET "fosters a good old boys’ club atmosphere" where the "misogynistic culture ... begins at the top," and that her employment was terminated unfairly while she was on leave for breast cancer. In her suit, she raises concerns about pay disparity, mistreatment of women in meetings, advancement decisions and a lack of credit. She also describes the alleged derogatory comments and intimidation she faced from former president of programming Stephen Hill and accuses BET of not treating it seriously enough and later, tarnishing her reputation in comments to the press.

The lawsuit asserts causes of action for gender discrimination, hostile workplace, violation of the Family Medical Leave Act, Violation of the Equal Pay Act, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, wrongful discharge in violation of public policy, defamation and more.

READ: : Former Top BET Exec Claims "Misogynistic Culture" in Discrimination Lawsuit

To which BET responds in a motion to dismiss filed on Tuesday that "it is unclear from her Complaint which allegation(s) is/are intended to support which claim(s) for relief."

"No one should have to guess," the defendant continues. "Indeed, due process compels that Mashariki provide sufficient notice of what facts she contends support her claims as to each of the named Defendants."

BET also is aiming to defeat certain claims with prejudice, meaning Mashariki wouldn't be allowed to amend those. Among them, the cable network disputes the legal viability of Mashariki's claim of defamation.

Mashariki's departure from BET was met with a great deal of confusion. When word got out in late March that she was exiting the network, it appears to have caused some surprise. Mashariki's lawyer insisted then that her client "was not terminated prior to taking medical leave," with network insiders telling the press she was indeed let go because of performance issues that predated her claims of discrimination and retaliation.

According to BET's filing, she was informed on February 28 — the day before she was scheduled to return — that her employment was being terminated, but that out of "compassion and empathy," the network agreed to make the effective date of her termination April 11 after a newly extended leave.

READ: : Stephen Hill, BET President of Programming, Exits Amidst Viacom Restructuring

There appears to be some factual dispute here, something the judge probably won't take up at the moment, but what is drawing attention in the short term are those statements to the press about Mashariki's performance and departure.

BET says some of the statements are "too vague to be actionable." This includes a senior BET executive telling employees she was "faking" her condition. It also includes how the company had described Mashariki as "misrepresent[ing] the facts" in her own communications with colleagues.

Some of the comments rising to alleged defamation appear to have been given to the press "on background," meaning quotes allowed, but no attribution. Now, BET's lawyer is arguing that Mashariki has failed "to plead sufficient (critical) facts such as who the purported speaker was, and to whom, in what context, or when the statement was purportedly made."

BET is also arguing that a couple of the comments aren't actionable because they aren't untrue.

"Here, Mashariki admits she was told on February 28, 2017, that her employment was being terminated," the motion states. "Thus, BET’s CEO’s statement that Mashariki would be 'departing the network' and, later, [BET senior vp communications Tracy] McGraw’s alleged 'confirmation' that Ms. Mashariki was 'no longer with the network' were both true statements."

It's also argued that Mashariki has failed to plead malice in her defamation claim, which could prime a side dispute over whether the former TV executive qualifies as a "public figure."

Here's the full dismissal motion.

Separately, Viacom is asking for an exit from the lawsuit on the basis that Mashariki has failed to show how Viacom could be considered her employer or liable as BET's corporate parent.

Nevertheless, both Viacom and BET are employing the same lawyer in this battle — Elena Baca at Paul Hastings.

This article was originally published on The Hollywood Reporter

From the Web

More on Vibe

Paras Griffin/Getty Images for BET)

Pandora’s Sound On: Spring Campaign Features Khalid, 2 Chainz And More

To usher in the spring season, Pandora designed a new playlist for select cities to help users enhance and amplify their listening experiences.

"We here at Pandora are launching a brand new campaign that amplifies the moment you’re in and helps you discover your unique sound—the music that moves you, the rhythm that fuels you, the album that inspires you to be you," a statement from Pandora's representatives reads.

Choosing iconic locations across America like Nashville, San Francisco, Oakland, New York City, Miami, and Atlanta, these select places have been given their own individual codes that lead to a customized playlist that coincides with the artist's work.

"We’ve commissioned leading street artists to create wall murals that depict their unique interpretations of sound and spring discovery. Each mural will have a QR code that leads to a customized playlist curated by each mural artist and reflects the music that inspired their work."

Some of the big names in music who appear on these playlists include Khalid, 2 Chainz, John Legend, and Becky G with a host of other popular artists. Though most of the playlist represents the artwork created in these select cities, there are hip-hop and R&B influences that make them exciting to listen to.


Continue Reading
Theo Wargo/Getty Images

Red Bull Music Festival Returns To NYC With FKA Twigs, Teyana Taylor, And More

With the start of festival season gearing up, the Red Bull Music Festival will return to New York City from April 30 - May 18, bringing big names to killer venues. Pulling FKA Twigs, Teyana Taylor, Tierra Whack and more to the Tristate area, the 10-day event is sure to kick spring up a notch.

FKA Twigs will play at Park Ave Armory from May 11-12, while Rosalía will perform at one of the first shows of the refurbished Webster Hall on April 30, a night they’re calling “Rosalía: El Mal Querer.” Teyana Taylor will go on May 15 at the Grand Ballroom at the Manhattan Center for a show called “House of Petunia.” On May 10, Tierra Whack will perform at the Rainbow Room.

For a total of 10 shows, each day will feature a different artist who has partnered with the festival to bring some of their music to life. Tickets can also be purchased here.

Other acts that will be present during the two-week festival include Moor Mother, NYXO, and JPEGMAFIA.

Continue Reading
Tabatha Fireman/Getty Images

J. Cole's Dreamville Festival Taps SZA, Big Sean, 21 Savage And More

After 2018's Dreamville Festival was canceled due to Hurricane Florence, J. Cole has returned with a similar lineup to make up for the past cancelation. Working with SZA, Nelly, and more, the two artists add to a stacked roster of old and new faces.

Cole himself is expected to perform alongside Big Sean, 21 Savage, Teyana Taylor, as well as Dreamville cohorts Bas, Ari Lennox, Omen, Lute, and more.

The one-day event will take place April 6 at Dorothea Dix Park in Raleigh, North Carolina. For a limited time, tickets for the festival will be available for purchase for $119, while VIP packages will include JV VIP ($240), Varsity VIP ($289), and MVP VIP ($449). Tickets can be purchased at DreamvilleFest.com.

We backkkkkkkkk.


TICKETS ON SALE AT https://t.co/[email protected] @dreamvillE pic.twitter.com/jDP7Iew5Ce

— J. Cole (@JColeNC) March 19, 2019

Continue Reading

Top Stories