New York Comic Con had a #TBT extravaganza and it wasn’t even Thursday. The OG cast of All That—the epic sketch show on Nickelodeon that ran for 10 seasons from 1994 to 2005 (think SNL for kids)—reunited on Saturday (Oct. 10). The Splat wrangled up Josh Server, Danny Tambarelli, Lori Beth Denberg and Kel Mitchell for a fun-filled sprint down memory lane for the Nickelodeon kids and kidults.
After a montage of the show’s most beloved sketches (including All That alum, Amanda Bynes and Kenan Thompson, who were sadly M.I.A. for the reunion) set to the infectious TLC theme song brought the feels, the cast brought the LOLs (Danny even brought five ears of corn) for what was truly a ’90s affair.
Cue all the #VitalInformation from the weekend panel below.
“They just asked me to be on the show.” — Danny Tambarelli on being invited to join the cast of All That after The Adventures of Pete & Pete and Figure It Out
Ever wonder what happened to the big ear of corn?? We have to carry his babies #allthatreunion https://t.co/Mi7TKGhyFM
— Danny Tamberelli (@dtamberelli) October 10, 2015
“I’m running for President in 2020!” — Danny pulls a Kanye
“You would be in the wardrobe room, the makeup room and eventually you just forgot that and people would just watch you interact on the show but it was like being in a fish bowl. It was a strange but awesome thing.” — Josh Server on working at Nickelodeon Studios in Orlando
“I’ll say something about slime. What’s funny about things like that was saying, ‘Oh, part of my job is having things dumped on me every day.’ You get good at it. I tried not to [taste the slime] … Also, because very little traction when you’re walking when you have slime in your butt crack and this is something I know from experience.” — Lori Beth about her slimiest encounter on the job
“I feel like I did the entire first season [of All That], impersonating Jim Carrey.” — Josh on his comedic influences
“I’m just gonna break stuff and use my body and not care about it as much.” — Danny on switching up his comedic style from Pete & Pete to All That
“It was kinda like The Weekend Update [on SNL], a little quieter but still crazy, and that was the fun of that bit is saying a bunch of crazy stuff very seriously.” — Lori Beth on the genius of “Vital Information”
“Me and Kenan had to do a segment with Oprah and we thought she was going to flip out [on us] but she was okay with it.” — Kel on his character, Okrah Winfrey
“You’re going to wear the fuzzy slippers so from then on, I had a different pair of fuzzy animal slippers every time I was Connie Muldoon, whether you saw my feet or not.” — Lori Beth on Good Burger character, Connie Muldoon
“At first, Miss Fingerly was a teacher that all the kids could play tricks on then like many characters on All That, slowly went insane.” — Lori Beth on her crazy teacher sketch, Miss Fingerly
“If you didn’t know how to get out of a sketch, you call the cops or jump out the window.” — Lori Beth on closing out a sketch
“It didn’t smell bad. It was the best thing ever.” — Danny on “Fat Cop” suit
“Every character that had a job was bad at their job.” — Lori Beth on the All That M.O.
“I would love to get my hands on some Ear Boy ears. Just smash Halloween.” — Josh on taking home his props as Ear Boy
“When we did Fallon, that was awesome and we’ve been talking about it. There’s been a big buzz about that.” — Kel on bringing Kenan back